Skip to content

Professor Turkey – Having Trouble With Reality

December 31, 2013

By Paul Homewood

 

Scientists and passengers from the Akademik Shokalskiy stomp flat an area of ice

Scientists and passengers from the Akademik Shokalskiy stomp flat an area of ice next to their ship in readiness for a helicopter evacuation after the Aurora Australis icebreaker failed to break through

 

 

 

Expedition leader, Chris Turney, seems a bit put out by “climate sceptics who have taken to social media sites in recent days to attack the scientific consensus on climate change”. (Yes, the same consensus that predicted less Antarctic ice).

Apparently they have been “pointing out the apparent incongruity of there being so much sea ice around the Shokalskiy in the middle of the Antarctic summer.”

 

He assures us that their problem is just a little local difficulty:

“There’s a misconception here – we are not trapped in new ice that’s been created because its cold,” said Turney. “This is very old, thick ice that’s been re-mobilised. It was attached to another part of the continent and has broken out and, with the south-easterly winds we’ve had, has pushed it up against the coast … and pinned us in.”

 

Well’ at least it’s honest of him to admit that the “very old, thick ice” is still there and has not melted away over the years. But, he still seems to have no appreciation, or is afraid to admit it, that all around Antarctica, sea ice has been steadily building up since satellite records began in 1979, and that ice extent has been at record levels for most of this year.

 

S_stddev_timeseries_thumb

http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/index.html

 

seaice.anomaly.antarctic

http://arctic.atmos.uiuc.edu/cryosphere/IMAGES/seaice.anomaly.antarctic.png

 

 

Perhaps the wind has been blowing in the wrong direction for the last 30 years.

Or perhaps, Professor Turkey has not done his homework properly.

10 Comments
  1. December 31, 2013 6:53 pm

    But BUT really Capt the models tell us this is thin rotten ice now full speed ahead or we will stop payment on the check from the taxpayers . ;>)

  2. A C Osborn permalink
    December 31, 2013 7:11 pm

    They have given us the best end to 2013 there could be, other than the complete collapse of the AGW scam of course.
    A Happy & Prosperous New Year to you Paul.

  3. GregO permalink
    December 31, 2013 8:45 pm

    Professor Turkey doesn’t like what he hears on skeptical blogs? My my.

    He richly deserves everything he is getting. We really must remember to thank him and his ship-of-fools for providing this end-of-year entertainment.

    He should appreciate that at least we are paying attention to him and his little band of media-whores. Attention? Isn’t that what they are there for?

    Truth about Antarctic sea ice extant seems to have escaped the dear Professor. Perhaps a resolution to read skeptic climate blogs a bit closer is in order for Professor Turkey – a sort of self-improvement resolution.

    Paul – love the blog! Happy New Year! Keep up the great work!

  4. rah permalink
    December 31, 2013 9:05 pm

    Captain Turkey is not the only one having problems dealing with reality.

    U.K. Guardian reporter Laurence Topham is tired and misses his Mommy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2zaXJ2ntJo&feature=youtu.be

    I mean really! No milk shakes?
    Hard Bed and his back hurts?
    He’s not having fun anymore and his leg hurts?

    It pretty much speaks for it’s self, but man oh man what a self absorbed whinny wuss this guy is. He is warm. He is fed. He is in a fascinating place on an adventure. He even has a little privacy it appears and obviously the ability to communicate long distances. He signed up to propagandize for a global warming expedition to the arctic! But Mommy I wanna go home now, it’s not fun anymore! Let us hope he never procreates if he can because quite obviously his “Y” Chromosome is little y and not a capital Y.

    • GregO permalink
      December 31, 2013 10:28 pm

      They’re running low on booze, it’s no fun anymore, people are making fun of them….all the makings of a boondoggle gone bad.

      Well, I do wish them the best – they are still in harm’s way – hope no one get chapped lips or wind burn or anything else.

      This was a mission that need not have been taken. They all should have stayed home. They could write and blog about disappearing sea-ice; and evil energy companies, and Mankind encroaching on a fragile environment.

      And now they demonstrate; polar environments are anything but fragile; while trapped in fast-growing sea-ice! Boneheads.

      If they make it out alive, they should count themselves among the fortunate.

      • rah permalink
        December 31, 2013 11:33 pm

        The Chinese have a helicopter and I’m wondering why the hold up in evacuating them? I know weather was a factor earlier. Is it still the problem? Or is there something else going on we haven’t heard about yet? Nobody had indicated that anyone is in any real danger yet. But obviously there is a question of what will be the fate of the ship.

      • Brian H permalink
        January 1, 2014 11:05 am

        Range and visibility appear to be part of it, plus the Chinese can’t take them anywhere at the moment. Escaping from your personal Unintended Consequences can be so complicated!

  5. January 1, 2014 2:09 am

    “There’s a misconception here – we are not trapped in new ice that’s been created because its cold,” said Turney. “This is very old, thick ice that’s been re-mobilised. It was attached to another part of the continent and has broken out and, with the south-easterly winds we’ve had, has pushed it up against the coast … and pinned us in.”

    I blame George Bush & evil wizards from space. But mostly George Bush (because those evil wizards from space are mean & they don’t like people who talk smack).

  6. January 1, 2014 2:19 am

    The Chinese have an evil sense of humour, making them wait. They are not globull warming true believers…

  7. Doug Bright permalink
    January 3, 2014 6:00 am

    Now sit right back and you’ll hear a tale
    A tale of a fateful trip
    They traveled to Antarctica
    Aboard a Russian ship

    The chief was a global warming man
    The skipper wasn’t so sure
    But activists set sail that day
    For a propaganda tour… a propaganda tour

    The water started getting cold
    The frozen ship was stuck
    Their theories called for melting ice
    But they were out of luck… yes, they were out of luck…

    The ship ran aground on this block of unexpected ice
    With embarrassment….
    And skeptics too…
    But we spend millions on a hoax

    While movie stars
    Professors and politicians
    Give us contempt and bile

    So this is the tale of climate change
    It’s here for a long, long time
    No matter how much their theories fail
    Truth has an uphill climb

    The government and Hollywood too
    Will do their very best
    To make us all uncomfortable
    In our sustainable nest

    No phone, no lights, no motor cars
    Not a single luxury
    Like Robinson Crusoe
    As primitive as can be

    The elites won’t join us though, my friends
    They’re sure to live in style
    While we give up our light bulbs
    Recant your climate change denial!

Comments are closed.