David Attenborough & The Population Matters Organisation
By Paul Homewood
Apparently the new Antarctic research vessel is to be named after David Attenborough. It is perhaps worth reflecting then that he is a patron of the Population Matters organisation, which quotes him as saying:
Their website lists these Policy Positions:
Along with consumption growth and industrial practices, population growth increases damage to the environment and depletes natural resources. We believe that human numbers should be reduced voluntarily to a sustainable level that enables an acceptable quality of life for all.
A stable and ethical transition to a sustainable population level would take several generations. Given that human activity already exceeds Earth’s capacity to support it at an acceptable consumption level for all, mainly due to overconsumption in the developed world, we should begin without delay.
Development and climate change
Population growth increases the number of wealthy carbon emitters and poorer climate change victims and hampers mitigation and adaptation efforts. Meeting the unmet need for family planning services is a cost-effective strategy. We support “contraction and convergence with a population base year” to achieve climate equity, i.e. reducing inequality in carbon emissions per head by allocating to each country a fixed tonnage of carbon emissions based on equal shares.
Women’s rights and reproductive health
Women’s empowerment and gender equality are essential for reproductive health, economic development and population stabilization. We therefore support programmes to improve the status of women.
Reproductive health reduces poverty, empowers women and stabilizes population. We urge universal access to appropriate family planning services. This includes training for professionals and sex and relationships education.
Migration often results from conflict, poverty, inequality or population and consumption pressures. We call for fair trade terms and increased foreign aid and knowledge transfer to promote sustainable development, global justice and resilience. Such aid should support gender equality and sexual and reproductive health and rights.
Each country must limit its dependence on others and balance consumption and resources. For most countries, achieving sustainability would require decreased consumption and both smaller families and reduced immigration. Immigration policies should be nondiscriminatory and reflect asylum-seekers’ and refugees’ rights. Countries that have free movement of labour agreements with each other should coordinate their policies.
Ageing and parenthood
We reject the case that more young people are required to care for an increasing number of elderly. Those young people would in turn grow old — resulting in a pyramid scheme in which each generation impoverishes the next. Demand for labour instead should be met by enabling employment for untrained, underemployed and older people.
We believe governments should promote responsible parenthood and that subsidies should be limited to the first two children unless the family is living in poverty.
We support the principal recommendation of the Population Panel convened in the United Kingdom in 1973 — that a senior government official be responsible for addressing population-related issues.
Clearly their policies go way beyond simple population issues, and are highly political.
BTW – Another of their patrons is our old friend, Paul Ehrlich!!