Skip to content

Green Energy Fiasco

April 30, 2016

By Paul Homewood 


In an energy news round up:


GWPF carry a report from Germany’s Wirtschaft Woche:



Because of the boom of renewable energy, more and more wind turbines have to be switched off. The reason is power overloading. The network operators must turn down electricity generated from windmills when their power threatens to clog the network. Originally, this was intended only as an emergency measure. The operators of wind and solar parks, however, are being subsidised for electricity that is not produced.

For the grid operator Tennet alone, these costs added EUR 329 million in 2015 – two and a half times as much as in the previous year. The other network operators 50Hertz, Amprion and EnBW had a combined cost of 150 million euros, according to a survey of Wirtschaftswoche among the four network operators in Germany.



No surprise then that electricity in Germany is more expensive than ever, as Die Welt reports:


The online German national daily Die Welt has a piece by business journalist Holger Zschäpitz on Germany’s sky-high, ever climbing electricity prices.

Awhile ago it looked as if prices had finally stabilized. But now Zschäpitz writes that German electricity prices, already among the highest in the world, have jumped once again.

To put the situation in perspective he writes: “Power consumers are now more burdened than automobile drivers” — who are brutally taxed to begin with. In Germany, even in these times of rock-bottom petroleum prices, motorists still cough up some 5 euros ($5.60) every single US gallon for gasoline they buy. Recently, proposals have been made to tax large cars even more, and to massively subsidize electric cars (which would be forced to charge up on the exorbitantly expensive electricity).

According to a recent analysis, writes Zschäpitz, “Consumers are now paying more for their power than ever before” — some 30.27 euro cents per kilowatt hour. Families today are paying 21% more for electricity than they did 5 years ago.

So what is driving the rapid upward price spiral?

Zschäpitz reports that it’s due mostly to the “Energiewende” – Germany’s push away from nuclear and fossil generated power to renewables such as wind, solar and biogas. Also driving the price are the energy price breaks that are granted to big power consumers, and liability costs for offshore wind parks. Moreover Zschäpitz reports that consumers are also forced to pick up the tab for upgrading the power grid so that it is able to handle the wildly fluctuating power supply from wind and sun.

In the meantime, Germany’s CO2 emissions have been rising, and thus consumers are not really getting anything for the massive amounts of money.

To illustrate the distortion gripping the German power market, Zschäpitz tells readers that today only 27% of the power price is made up of “pure raw material costs”. The electricity production cost by itself has in fact “fallen by 25% over the past few years“. However this cost reduction has been offset and more by other feed-in and grid operating surcharges levied as a result of the Energiewende. This leads Die Welt’s Zschäpitz to conclude:

“Thus power consumers are now more burdened with state taxes and fees than automobile drivers.”

For relief, power consumers do have the option of switching to private power providers, and doing so is non-problematic, Zschäpitz writes. However one thing is sure: Electricity prices are expected to keep rising.



Meanwhile, Tata Steel boss hits out at UK energy prices in front of the Business Select Committee:



GEORGE OSBORNE risks killing off British manufacturing with sky-high green taxes and business rates – the Indian boss of the Port Talbot steelworks blasted today.

Tata Steel chief Bimlendra Jha said his UK business would be MAKING money if it had Germany’s electricity prices.

And he told MPs that the Government’s existing policies – such as eco taxes which send energy costs through the roof – meant it was almost impossible for firms “bleeding money” to recover.


(Readers may recall that Germany took the decision to protect its own energy intensive industry from the costs of the Energiewende).

  1. April 30, 2016 3:27 pm

    Reblogged this on Climatism and commented:
    “In the meantime, Germany’s CO2 emissions have been rising, and thus consumers are not really getting anything for the massive amounts of money.”

    So much pain for so little gain.

    Not to mention the CO2 emitted from China and India to manufacture all those ‘green’ industrial windmills.

  2. Joe Public permalink
    April 30, 2016 5:12 pm

    That’s only part of the problem with the renewables capacity in Energiewende.

    From Fraunhofer:

    Hover mouse over bar at top, select ‘Power’, click ‘Electricity production in Germany’. Then from selection options menu on left, again select 2015, July, All Sources.

    From the Fuels & Sources above the chart, deselect all except Solar and ensure ‘Import Balance’ & ‘Stacked’ remain selected.

    This shows that much of Germany’s solar has to be exported. In fact the gold- & purple-coloured areas beneath the X-axis exceed the area of the (solar) area above the x-axis most of the time that month.

    Resultant screen capture:

    The screencap suggests that except for a few hours of a few days, the equivalent of nearly all Germany’s solar generation that month had to be exported.

    • ralfellis permalink
      May 2, 2016 8:42 am

      Denmark has been doing the same since 2005. They cannot use all their wind power, so they export it to Scandinavia, who can easily turn off their hydro plants at the flick of a switch. And then Denmark reimports the energy when the wind drops.

      A good system, you might think. However, Scandinavia doubles the price of the stored energy, so Denmark is paying through the nose to use the Scandinavian storage facility. This is always the trouble with renewables, you don’t just pay a hugely inflated price to generate the electricity, you pay double again to store it somewhere. And if Denmark did not have a land of mountains just to the north, they would be in real doo-doo. What does Holland do, to store its energy?

      Why Wind Power Works in Denmark (they do not use it….)

      Click to access CIEN.158.2.66.pdf


  3. April 30, 2016 8:00 pm

    Too bad that companies and governments spent huge amount of money for green energy (without calculating first the costs, the results, and it’s impact over environment) and then don’t use it. Wind energy is somehow controversial, as mentioned before, on this site and on other sites, especially offshore wind farms.

  4. Graeme No.3 permalink
    May 1, 2016 10:38 am

    I understand that in the UK wind turbines ordered not to generate collect twice what they would get if they overloaded the grid. Well,
    100 turbines NOT working = shortage of electricity
    600 turbines NOT working = shortage of electricity
    100 turbines working = glut of electricity
    600 turbines working = glut of electricity

    So you MUST subsidise them working or not. And MUST install more of them. If you cannot see any problem with the foregoing for which party will you be a candidate?

    • Robert Jones permalink
      May 1, 2016 5:46 pm

      Graeme No.3, I have now read your comment, carefully, three times and it is still utter nonsense. If wind turbines are ordered to cease working it is because the national grid is unable to handle their output, in other words there is a glut of electricity, not a shortage.

      Wind turbines are intermittent, unreliable, kill wildlife and cause those people living in the vicinity damaging health problems. As a product of the deeply-flawed, Labour-drafted Climate Change Act (2008) they should be withdrawn from service immediately so that their owners meet the decommissioning costs directly (as opposed to using ‘front’ companies). They have made a fortune for their owners and driven the rest of us into fuel poverty.

      Keep taking your medication.

  5. May 1, 2016 10:44 am

    Bavaria is one of the main stumbling blocks as they don’t want either turbines or transmission lines scarring the countryside.

    ‘It appears the brakes have been effectively applied to the scenery pollution industry.’

  6. tom0mason permalink
    May 1, 2016 2:59 pm

    While the UK makes the market for Chinese made diesel generators —

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: